LAST STAND

 

 

Home

About Us

Hot Topics

Calendar

Donations  

Join Us!

What's New?

Our Stands

Green Links

Home

We want to be clear that Last Stand is not opposed to an assisted-living facility in Key West, and we're not necessarily opposed to its being sited on the Truman Waterfront parcel being given the city.  We are concerned with the process.  This commentary by Solares Hill editor David Ethridge was in the May 21 issue of Solares Hill and was also run in the Key West Citizen

Elders Promised Assisted Living Facility at Truman

After several years absence, we went to a city commission meeting Tuesday evening just to see what we had been missing. It was a decision with all the native savvy that impelled us to go to Canada in March. Tops on the commission's agenda, and the subject that had brought me out, was the debate over siting an assisted living facility on four acres of the 35-acre parcel of land the Navy is giving Key West at Truman Annex. The question is not whether such a facility is needed — everyone agrees that it is — the question is where. After a search that lasted a couple of years, it came down to the Truman Annex or a parcel next to the botanical garden on Stock Island. The elderly in the community wanted a decision; something definitive they could latch onto that would prove the city really intended to address their needs and was prepared to take the first steps.

No one at the meeting opposed the Truman site, they simply felt the city was getting ahead of itself. They pointed out that the city had hired a consultant to produce a master plan for the 35 acres and argued that that plan should come first. Which would be sensible planning. But sensible was not why most in the audience were there. They wanted the city's promise and they wanted it now.

The commission chambers were close to full by the 6 p.m. start of the meeting with every single elderly person in Key West in attendance. Assisted living was high on the agenda, but what with the Pledge of Allegiance, a couple of awards to staff for stellar service, and a six-month budget recap, it took two hours to get there.

First were letters from Virginia Panico and Liz Kern urging passage. Then came an impassioned plea from Jean Marie Weatherhead who told a compelling story of caring for her father afflicted with Alzheimer's, working all the while as he spent two years on the waiting list for help, the worry and the anxiety a constant in her life and no place to go for assistance. "Pass this resolution," she said simply. The audience, already in favor, was moved. Next was poor George Halloran representing Last Stand. Halloran has been a city commissioner and has often had to argue the unpopular side of issues as he and Last Stand staunchly defended Key West against the Huns at the gates. Once again he was cast into that role, and once again it was lonesome standing amidst this pack of insistent seniors.

The resolution Tuesday night was not about the good guys squaring off with the bad guys to deny Key West an assisted living facility. This was about the good guys facing off with other good guys to achieve the same end. But that night, the elders were not willing to take an IOU from the city. They wanted the promise in writing, and they were there in large numbers to emphasize the point.

Their opponents were few but they were defending an excellent point. Why attempt the development of the 35 acres in a piecemeal fashion, the same kind of from-the-hip zoning that has gotten us in so much trouble in the past. Why constrain the architects and planners we have hired by excising a large and exceedingly valuable piece of property from the whole. "Yeah, yeah," say the elders. "We have already been waiting for two years. What guarantee can you give us that it won't be another two years. Pass the resolution and pass it now..."

Ed Swift, who has led the search committee for two years, related the problems in finding a perfect site and how it is important to have such a facility integrated into the rest of the city, not isolated. Joan Higgs agreed strongly and then Sandy Higgs got the microphone and instructed everyone who was present for this particular issue to stand up. I was there as a reporter so protocol dictates I should not demonstrate my feelings, but I've got to tell you, if you are one of the two people sitting in a room of 300 standees and you notice your ally, George Halloran, is looking particularly goofy and could easily be mistaken for a sexual predator, you look for cover. I pretended to drop my pencil and then scutter around under the seats as if I had business there.

The seniors got what they wanted; who in that room was going to vote against them? Surely not I.

— D.E.

 RETURN TO HOT TOPICS

RETURN TO HOME PAGE